Skip to main content

Table 2 The frequency of risk factors which contribute to occurrence of suicidal behavior among people with dementia and their caregivers identified in the selected studies

From: Similarities and differences in the prevalence and risk factors of suicidal behavior between caregivers and people with dementia: a systematic review

 

Frequency of being investigated

Risk factors associated with suicidal behavior in both people with dementia and their caregivers

 (1) Higher severity of depression and anxiety

• In people with dementia: 7 studies ([31, 34, 45, 46, 50, 52, 54])

• In caregivers of people with dementia: 6 studies ([17, 20,21,22, 24, 26])

 (2) Pre-existing mental health problem

• In people with dementia: 2 studies [19, 48]

• In caregivers of people with dementia: 2 studies [23, 28]

 (3) Pre-existing physical health condition

• In people with dementia: 1 study [52]

• In caregivers of people with dementia: 3 studies ([23, 24, 26])

 (4) Presence of or more severe behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD)

• In people with dementia: 1 study [47]

• In caregivers of people with dementia: 1 study [21]

Risk factors associated with suicidal behavior only in people with dementia

 (1) Shortly or within 3 months after diagnosis of dementia

7 studies [36, 47, 48, 50, 52, 53, 55]

 (2) Younger age of diagnosis (50 to 69 years old)

4 studies [36, 45, 48, 52]

 (3) History of inpatient psychiatric hospitalization

3 studies [37, 38, 50]

 (4) Alzheimer’s disease alone

2 studies [19, 47]

 (4) Passive self-harm

2 studies [33, 37]

 (4) Better cognitive function

2 studies [43, 47]

 (4) Advanced dementia

2 studies [47, 49]

 (8) Higher thought and concentration disturbance

1 study [34]

 (8) Worsening of cognitive decline

1 study [34]

 (8) Mixed Alzheimer’s disease and vascular dementia

1 study [31]

 (8) Lower degree of wish to live

1 study [31]

 (8) Greater degree of wish to die

1 study [31]

 (8) Reduced quality of life

1 study [47]

 (8) Stress and hopelessness

1 study [45]

 (8) Delusional symptoms

1 study [54]

 (8) Antidementia medication prescription

1 study [54]

 (8) Higher level of daily functioning

1 study [49]

 (8) Previous suicidal attempts

1 study [49]

 (8) Recent mild cognitive impairment

1 study [53]

 (8) Living in rural area

1 study [55]

 (8) Chronic pain

1 study [55]

 (8) Substance use

1 study [55]

 (8) Comorbid Parkinson’s disease

1 study [45]

 (8) Prescription of antidepressant and anxiolytic medication

1 study [50]

 (8) Moderate dementia

1 study [54]

Risk factors associated with suicidal behavior only in caregivers of people with dementia

 (1) Absence of social and family support

2 studies ([24, 26])

 (2) Emotional burnout

1 study [17]

 (2) Depersonalization

1 study [17]

 (2) Lower self-esteem

1 study [22]

 (2) Dysfunctional coping

1 study [22]

 (2) Higher burden of care

1 study [17]

 (2) Insomnia

1 study [8]

 (2) Feeling lonely

1 study [24]

 (2) Lower sense of competence and mastery

1 study [24]

 (2) Poor mental health

1 study [22]

 (2) Unemployment

1 study [26]

 (2) Living without a partner

1 study [26]

 (2) Impaired social, physical and emotional function

1 study [26]

 (2) Care receiver related factors (impairment in basic activities such as eating, dressing, bathing, and maintaining personal hygiene; incontinence)

1 study [21]