Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of the included RCTs (n = 24)

From: Effectiveness of computer-based interventions for community-dwelling people with cognitive decline: a systematic review with meta-analyses

Authors; Country

Type of cognitive decline

Sample size (IGa/CGb)

Intervention

Control

Duration in weeks

Sessions/week, (minutes/session)

Setting

Cinar et al. 2020; [45] Turkey

SCDc

60 (30/30)

PCd

No intervention

12 (or at least 1200 min of training)

about 7 (15–20 min)

Home

Amjad et al. 2019; [50] Pakistan

MCIe - not specified

38 (18/20)

VRf

Physical exercises (motion, stretching)

6

5 (20–30 min)

Lab

Barnes et al. 2009; [51] USA

MCI - all types

47 (22/25)

PC

Alternative computer-based activities

6

5 (100 min)

Home

Damirchi et al. 2018; [52] Iran

MCI - not specified

44 (11/11/13/9)

IG1: PC

Waiting list group

8

3 (30 min in weeks 1–6;

60 min in 7th and 8th week)

Lab

IG2: Physical activity group

IG3: IG1 combined with physical group activities

Dimitriadis et al. 2016; [53] Greece

MCI - not specified

158 (53/50/55)

ARg

CG1: Alternative computer-based activity

10

4 (90 min)

Home

CG2: Waiting list group

Finn et al. 2011; [54] Australia

MCI - amnestic multiple domain

16 (8/8)

PC

Waiting list group

average of 11.4 h

4–5 (not reported)

Home

Flak et al. 2019; [55] Norway

MCI - all types

69 (35/34)i

PC

Same intervention as in IG but in contrast with fixed low level of difficulty

5

5 (30–40 min)

Home

Hagovska et al. 2017; [46] Slovakia

MCI - not specified

60 (30/30)

PC

Group cognitive training program

10

2 (30 min)

Lab

Han et al. 2017; [56] South Korea

MCI - all types

43 (43/42)j

Tablet

Usual treatment

4

2 (30 min)

Lab

Herrera et al. 2012; [57] France

MCI - amnestic multiple domain

22 (11/11)

PC

Cognitive training

12

2 (60 min)

Lab

Hyer et al. 2016; [58] USA

MCI - amnestic and non-amnestic

68 (34/34)

PC

Same intervention as in IG but in contrast with fixed low level of difficulty

5–7

about 5 (40 min)

Lab or Home

Li et al. 2019; [59] China

MCI - amnestic (due to ADk)

141 (78/63)

PC

No intervention

24

3–4 (about 40 min)

Home

Lin et al. 2016; [60] USA

MCI - amnestic multiple domain (due to AD)

21 (10/11)

PC

Cognitive training

6

4 (60 min)

Home

Nousia et al. 2019; [48] Greece

MCI - all types

46 (25/21)

PC

Usual treatment

15

2 (60 min)

Lab

Park et al. 2019; [49] South Korea

MCI - single and multiple domain

21 (10/11)

Mixed Reality

Computer-based cognitive training

6

3 (30 min)

Lab

Park et al. 2020; [61] South Korea

MCI - amnestic

21 (10/11)

VR

Waiting list group

12

2 (30 min)

Lab

Rosen et al. 2011; [62] USA

MCI - amnestic

12 (6/6)

PC

Alternative computer-based activities

Average of 8 l

5 (100 min)

Home

Savulich et al. 2017; [63] United Kingdom

MCI - amnestic (due to AD)

42 (21/21)

Tablet

No intervention

4

not reported (60 min)

Lab

Thapa et al. 2020; [64] South Korea

MCI - not specified

68 (34/34)m

VRn

Educational program on general health care

8

3 (100 min)

Lab

Cinar et al. 2020; [45] Turkey

Dementia - AD

60 (30/30)

PC

No intervention

12 (or at least 1200 min of training)

about 7 (15–20 min)

Home

Galante et al. 2007; [65] Italy

Dementia - AD

12 (7/5)o

PC

Interviews on current affairs and participants’ lives

4

3 (60 min)

Lab

Heiss et al. 1994; [66] Germany

Dementia - AD

70 (18/17/18/17)

IG1: PC

Social support

24

2 (60 min)

Lab

IG2p: IG1 combined with medication

IG3p: IG1 combined with medication

Karssemeijer et al. 2019; [67, 68] The Netherlands

Dementia - all types

115 (38/38/39)

IG1: VR (combined with cycling on a stationary bike)

Physical exercises (relaxation, flexibility)

12

3 (30–40 min)

Lab

IG2: Cycling on a stationary bike

Lee et al. 2013; [47] China

Dementia - AD

19 (7/6/6)

IG1: Tablet

Waiting-list control group with cognitive activities

6

2 (12–30 min)

Lab

IG2: Cognitive training without Tablet

Yu et al. 2015; [69] China

Dementia - not specified

32 (16/16)

Tablet

Cognitive training

4–8

1–2 (30 min)

Lab

  1. aIG: intervention group
  2. bCG: control group
  3. cSCD: subjective cognitive decline
  4. dPC: personal computer
  5. eMCI: mild cognitive impairment
  6. fVR: virtual reality
  7. gAR: augmented reality
  8. hThe authors anticipated 6–10 weeks. Participants completed at least 80% of the sessions
  9. i68 (34/34) participants were included in the final analysis of the respectively study
  10. jCross-over randomized controlled trial
  11. kAD: Alzheimer’s disease
  12. lParticipants had to use the program until either achievement of asymptotic performance levels over a several day period or completion of 80% of the training material in a given exercise
  13. m66 (33/33) participants were included in the final analysis of the respectively study
  14. nThe intervention consists of two parts 1) cognitive training 2) educational program on general health care (as in CG)
  15. o11 (7/4) participants were included in the final analysis of the respectively study
  16. pThese intervention groups were not considered for analysis, because the medication used consisted of non-commercial substances for the treatment of dementia, as well as non-registered substances of the Austrian Register of Pharmaceutical Specialties