Skip to main content

Table 2 Characteristics of selected articles (n = 43)

From: Health outcomes and implementation barriers and facilitators of comprehensive geriatric assessment in community settings: a systematic integrative review [PROSPERO registration no.: CRD42021229953]

Characteristic

Controlled intervention studies (n = 31)

Pre-post without controls (n = 4)

Case control (n = 1)

Qualitative (n = 3)

Mixed methods (n = 4)

Total (n = 43)

Randomised controlled trials (n = 30)

Controlled pre-post study (n = 1)

Publication year

 2000–2005

8

   

1

2

11 (26%)

 2006–2010

7

 

2

1

  

10 (23%)

 2011–2015

4

 

1

  

1

6 (14%)

 2016–2020

11

1

1

 

2

1

16 (37%)

Country

 United States

6

 

1

1

 

1

9 (21%)

 Canada

3

     

3 (7%)

 Denmark

1

     

1 (2%)

 Finland

1

     

1 (2%)

 Italy

  

1

   

1 (2%)

 Netherlands

7

   

1

1

9 (21%)

 Norway

1

     

1 (2%)

 Spain

1

     

1 (2%)

 Sweden

4

    

1

4 (9%)

 Switzerland

2

     

2 (5%)

 Switzerland and Netherlands

  

1

   

1 (2%)

 United Kingdom

1

    

1

2 (5%)

 Australia

1

   

1

 

2 (5%)

 New Zealand

 

1

  

1

 

2 (5%)

 Hong Kong

1

     

1 (2%)

 South Korea

  

1

   

1 (2%)

 Taiwan

1

 

1

   

2 (5%)

Population age (years)

 ≥65

8

 

3

   

11 (25%)

 > 65

   

1

1

 

2 (5%)

 ≥70

4

     

4 (9%)

 > 70

2

     

2 (5%)

 ≥75

12

1

1

 

2

2

18 (42%)

 > 75

     

2

2 (5%)

 ≥80

3

     

3 (7%)

 70 to 84

1

     

1 (2%)

Where CGA is conducted

 Home

18

1

1

 

2

3

25 (58%)

 Primary care setting: General practice, elderly medical centre

5

 

1

1

 

1

8 (19%)

 Home and general practice

1

     

1 (2%)

 Home and phone

2

     

2 (5%)

 Secondary or Tertiary care setting: Outpatient geriatric clinic, outpatient geriatric unit, outpatient geriatric medical centre

3

 

2

   

5 (12%)

 Geriatric clinic and phone

1

     

1 (2%)

 Location not specified (but care setting confirmed to be in the community)

    

1

 

1 (2%)

CGA conducted by

 Nurse

16

1

2

 

1

2

22 (51%)

 Geriatrician

1

  

1

  

2 (5%)

 Geriatrician, nurse

2

    

1

3 (7%)

 Geriatrician, nurse, social worker

1

 

1

   

2 (5%)

 General practitioner, nurse

1

   

1

 

2 (5%)

 Nurse, occupational therapist

1

     

1 (2%)

 Physiotherapist, social worker

  

1

   

1 (2%)

 Nurse, physiotherapist, social worker

1

     

1 (2%)

 Nurse, social worker, pharmacist

2

     

2 (5%)

 Multidisciplinary team

4

   

1

1

6 (14%)

 Trained interviewers

1

     

1 (2%)