Skip to main content

Advertisement

Springer Nature is making SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19 research free. View research | View latest news | Sign up for updates

Table 3 Fidelity of delivery scores (mean %, (range %)) for components delivered across COTiD-UK sessions across sites

From: Measuring fidelity of delivery of the Community Occupational Therapy in Dementia-UK intervention

SiteSession (Mean % (Range %))
Introduction (1)OPHI (2)Ethnographic interview (3)Summary and Goal-setting (4&5)Consultation and advice (6)Evaluation (7)Summary and Goal-setting (2) (4&5 (2))b
 52.4% (26.7–86.7) or
47.5a (13.3–86.7)
75.5 (62.5–90.6)71.9 (56.3–84.4)71.7 (52.9–94.1)65.6 (30–86.7)69.0 (43.8–87.5)44.1 (29.4–55.9)
A26.7 (13.3a-40)76.6 (75–78.1)70.3 (62.5–78.1)57.4 (52.9–61.8)30.0 (30.0)68.8 (56.3–81.3)51.5 (47.1–55.9)
B58.3 (53.3–63.3)82.8 (78.1–87.5)76.6 (75–78.1)91.2 (88.2–94.1)86.7 (86.7)71.9 (68.8–75.0)
C35.0 (33.3–36.7)82.8 (75–90.6)70.3 (56.3–84.4)77.9 (73.5–82.4)55.0 (53.3–56.7)75.0 (75)
D55.0 (53.3–56.7)75.0 (68.8–81.3)75.0 (68.8–81.3)64.7 (61.8–67.7)80.0 (80.0)65.6 (56.3–75)
E28.3 (26.7–30)70.3 (62.5–78.1)75.0 (68.8–81.3)72.1 (52.9–91.2)75.0 (75)
F28.3 (13.3a-43.3)71.9 (65.6–78.1)67.2 (62.5–71.9)77.9 (70.6–85.3)63.3 (53.3–73.3)78.1 (75–81.3)
G68.3 (60–76.7)73.4 (65.6–81.3)68.8 (62.5–75.0)83.8 (76.5–91.2)71.7 (70–73.3)65.6 (56.3–75)
H68.3 (56.7–80)78.1 (75–81.3)68.8 (68.8)73.5 (67.7–79.4)71.7 (66.7–76.7)65.6 (56.3–75)
I26.7 (13.3a-40)73.4 (71.9–75)73.4 (65.6–81.3)64.7 (64.7)71.7 (70–73.3)43.8 (43.8)
J36.7 (33.3–40)73.4 (68.8–78.1)73.4 (65.6–81.3)63.2 (55.9–70.6)65.6 (62.5–68.8)
K60.0 (53.3–66.7)76.6 (68.8–84.4)71.9 (71.9)69.1 (58.8–79.4)46.7 (46.7)78.1 (75–81.3)
L78.4 (70–86.7)71.9 (65.6–78.1)71.9 (68.8–75.0)64.7 (64.7)53.3 (53.3)75.0 (62.5–87.5)29.4 (29.4)
  1. Note: Max fidelity (100%): Introduction: n=30, OPHI and Ethnographic interview: n = 32, Summary and Goal-setting: n = 34, Consultation and advice: n = 30, Evaluation: n = 16
  2. Components that were N/A are coded as missing and thus scored ‘0’ in percentage calculations, therefore fidelity for individual sets may be underestimated
  3. aThree session 1’s were missing – cannot tell fidelity of these. Can only tell if the observations have been carried out, thus leading to some sets having only 13.3% fidelity. Average without these data points also provided (without a) | b4&5(2) = second Summary and Goal-setting transcript when OTs have delivered 4&5 separately
  4. -: No transcript available
  5. To ensure site anonymity, site numbers have been shuffled up so that numbers 1–15 do not directly correspond to letters A-L