Skip to main content

Table 2 Results of Quality Appraisal using the Quality In Prognosis Studies (QUIPS) Tool Summary

From: Prognostic factors of depression and depressive symptoms after hip fracture surgery: systematic review

Author, year

Study participation

Study attrition

Prognostic factor measurement

Outcome measurement

Study confounding

Statistical analysis/reporting

Bruggeman 2007, Australia [28]

moderate

high

moderate

low

moderate

Low

Cristancho 2016, USA [15]

low

high

moderate

low

high

moderate

Deng, 2005, Taiwan [29]

low

high

high

high

high

high

Langer 2015, USA [30]

moderate

high

low

low

high

moderate

Lenze, 2007, USA [13]

low

low

low

low

moderate

moderate

Lenze, 2008, USA [31]

low

moderate

low

low

low

moderate

Lenze, 2005, USA [32]

low

low

low

low

high

high

Liu 2018, Taiwan [33]

low

moderate

moderate

low

moderate

high

Matheny, 2011, USA [34]

low

high

moderate

low

low

high

Shyu 2009, Taiwan [10]

low

low

moderate

low

high

high

Van der Ree, 2020, Netherlands [14]

low

moderate

low

low

high

low

Voshaar 2007, the Netherlands [35]

low

moderate

moderate

low

high

moderate