Skip to main content

Table 4 Joint display of patient acceptability ratings (n = 30)

From: Feasibility and acceptability of commonly used screening instruments to identify frailty among community-dwelling older people: a mixed methods study

Instrument

Very Easy/ Easy

n (%)

Participant comments (Easy/Very Easy)

Neutral/

Difficult

n (%)

Participant comments (Neutral/Difficult)

EFS

28 (96.6)

•Not as quick as I used to be

•It did show me what I can’t do anymore

•Easy but you need to think first.

•Easy enough

1 (3.4)

•Found it frustrating. The clock face. I don’t like these sorts of puzzles!

FQ

27 (96.4)

•I had no difficulty. I found it interesting.

•A bit of thinking

•Nothing hard about the questions

1 (3.6)

•n.a.

GAIT

25 (86.2)

•Easy to complete

•No issues to do

•Simple task

4 (13.8)

•It’s not easy, had to slow down, painful hip

•After sitting for a while, my legs cramp. I would have been quicker if I had not been sitting.

GFI

26 (89.7)

•Some questions could go either way. Sometimes yes/ sometimes no.

•Once I worked out the questions

•Went quickly enough

•No problems completing this

3 (10.3)

•You have to think - it can never be cut and dried.

•OK question - have to stop and think about questions as don’t normally think about these situations

KC

25 (89.3)

•I thought it was challenging, but rather appropriate and it made me realise how fortunate I am to be able to enjoy my activities, and the people in my life

•I’m always thankful for anything I can do

•Interesting - covered a whole gamut of day to day living

3 (10.7)

•Mostly easy, some didn’t apply

•My life has been very difficult over the last eighteen months

•Don’t normally go out much; socialise within street

P7

30 (100.0)

•No worries answering questions

•Simple and easy

0 (0.0

•n.a.

REFS

25 (96.2)

•Hated it. Don’t like this - not many people would.

•Had to think more about this one. Trying to do it a bit too quickly. Made me think.

•Didn’t have any problems. A long list of what you can’t do.

•Quite reasonable things to ask older persons

•Clock was a bit confusing - wasn’t sure of what the question meant re the numbering around the edge

1 (3.8)

•n.a.

ALL

186 (93.5)

 

13 (6.5)

 
  1. Abbreviations: P7 PRISMA-7, FQ Frail Questionnaire, GAIT: Gait Speed Test, GFI Groningen Frailty Indicator, GST Gait Speed Test, EFS Edmonton Frail Scale, KC Kihon Checklist, REFS Reported Edmonton Frail Scale