Table 5 Methodological quality of the measurement property “reliability” by the COSMIN and quality criteria of the measurement properties per assessment

ROAG

Andersson et al. (2002a) [18]

Good^a

?/−

(κ/κ^w: 0.45-0.84)^b

Nurse/Dental hygienist

Ribeiro et al. (2014) [37]

Good

+/−

(κ^w: 0.38-0.88)

Community health workers

MDS

Arvidson-Bufano et al. (1996) [28]

Poor^a

N.A.

Nurse/Dentist

Blank et al. (1996) [27]

Poor^a

N.A.

Nurse/Dentist

Cohen-Mansfield (2002) [28]

Poor^a

N.A.

Geriatricians/Dentist

Hawes et al. (1995) [31]

Poor

N.A.

Nurses

MDS-HC

Morris et al. (1997) [35]

Good

+/−

(κ^w: 0.57-0.7)

Nurses

OHAT

Chalmers et al. (2005) [17]

Fair

+ (ICC = 0.78)

? (κ: 0.51-0.80)^b

Fair

+ (ICC = 0.74)

? (κ: 0.48-0.80)^b

Poor

N.A.

Nurses

Simpelaere et al. (2016) [38]

Poor

N.A.

Fair

+ (ICC = 0.96)

? (κ: 0.83-1.00)

Fair

+ (ICC = 0.81 & 0.78)

? (κ: 0.14-0.91)

Speech pathologists

THROAT

Dickinson et al.(2001) [19]

Good

+/−

(κ^w: 0-0.96)

Good^a

+/−

(κ^w: 0.46-0.97)

Dental hygienist,/ stroke specialist nurse and staff Nurse

DHR

Fjeld et al. (2017) [29]

Fair

+

(κ: 0.7-0.8)

Fair^a

?

(κ: 0.4-0.8)

Dental hygienist and Nurse

MPS

Henriksen et al. (1999) [32]

Poor

N.A.

Poor^a

N.A.

Dentist, 2 Dental Hygienist, and Nurse

BOHSE

Kayser-Jones et al. (1995) [33]

Fair^a

-(r: 0.4-0.68)

? (κ: -0.02-0.82)^b

Fair

+/−

(r: 0.79-0.88)

Dentist and Nurses

Lin et al. (1999) [34]

Fair^a

?

(κ: -0.018-0.519)^b

Dentist and Nurses

OAS

Yanagisawa et al. (2017) [39]

Poor

N.A

Fair

? (κ: 0.25-0.90)

+/- (ICC: 0.54-0.98)

Dental professionals and care workers