Table 2 Data-extraction table for the included studies
Authors | Publication year | Study design | Investigated measurement property | Type of non-dental healthcare professional using assessment | Patient population | Oral health assessment | Rating scale | Duration of assessment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Andersson et al. [18] | 2002 | Cross-sectional observational | Inter-rater reliability | RN | older people in rehabilitation ward | ROAG | 3 point scale on 8 items | Unknown |
2 | Andersson et al. [25] | 2002 | Cross-sectional observational | Content validity | RN | Geriatric rehabilitation patients | ROAG | 3 point scale on 8 items | Unknown |
3 | Arvidson-Bufano et al. [26] | 1996 | Cross-sectional observational | Inter-rater reliability | RN and LPN | Nursing home residents | MDS-RAI (section M) and RAP summary | 2 Point scale on 7 items | 3–4 min |
4 | Blank et al. [27] | 1996 | Cross-sectional observational | Inter-rater reliability | RN and LPN | Nursing home residents | MDS-RAI (section M) and RAP summary | 2 Point scale on 7 items | Unknown |
5 | Chalmers et al. [17] | 2005 | Prognostic follow-up | Content validity Criterion validity Intra-rater reliability Inter-rater reliability Test-retest reliability | PCA, RN, Enrolled Nurses and NA | Residents from residential facilities | OHAT | 3 point scale on 8 items | Mean: 7.8 min |
6 | Cohen-Mansfield et al. [28] | 2002 | Cross-sectional observational study | Inter-rater reliability | Geriatricians | Nursing home residents with Dementia | MDS- mouth pain and inflamed gums | 8 items on 2 point scale | Unknown |
7 | Dickinson et al. [19] | 2001 | Cross-sectional study | Content validity Intra-rater reliability Inter-rater reliability | Stroke specialist nurse, staff nurses, student nurse | Older medically Ill patients | THROAT | 4 point scale on 9 items | Unknown |
8 | Fjeld et al. [29] | 2016 | Prognostic follow-up | Content validity Criterion validity Inter-rater reliability | Clinical nurse | Nursing home residents | DHR | 3 point scale on two items | Less than 1 minute |
9 | Hanne et al. [30] | 2012 | Cross-sectional | Cross-cultural validity | Nurses | Acute medical ward residents (mean age 76.5) | ROAG | 3 point scale on 8 items | Unknown |
10 | Hawes et al. [31] | 1995 | Cross-sectional | Inter-rater reliability | LN | Nursing home residents | MDS | Unclear | Unknown |
11 | Henriksen et al. [32] | 1999 | Cross-sectional | Intra-rater reliability Inter-rater reliability | Medical Nurse | older people with mental disabilities | MPS | 4 point scale on 2 items | 2–4 min |
12 | Kayser-Jones et al. [33] | 1995 | Cross-sectional | Inter-rater reliability Test-retest reliability | RN, LVN, CNA | Nursing home residents | BOHSE | 3 point scale on 10 items | Mean time RNs, LVNS, CNAs: 7.4, 7.9 and 8.7 min |
13 | Lin et al. [34] | 1999 | Cross-sectional | Criterion validity Inter-rater reliability | LN and CNA | LTC residents with Alzheimer | BOHSE | 3 point scale on 10 items | Unknown |
14 | Morris et al. [35] | 1997 | Cross-sectional | Inter-rater reliability | Nurses | Community-dwelling older people with home care | MDS-HC | Unclear | Unknown |
15 | Paulsson et al. [36] | 2008 | Prospective | Criterion validity | Nurses | Patients on medical ward (mean age 67) | ROAG | 3 point scale on 8 items | Unknown |
16 | Riberio et al. [37] | 2014 | Cross-sectional | Cross-cultural validity Criterion validity Intra-rater reliability | CHW | Community-dwelling older people | ROAG | 3 point scale on 8 items | 11 min |
17 | Simpelaere et al. [38] | 2016 | Cross-sectional with two- week follow-up for test-retest | Intra-rater reliability Inter-rater reliability Test-retest reliability | Speech Pathologists | Acute geriatric department/hospitalized, residential care settings (assisted living and nursing homes) | OHAT | 3 point scale on 8 items | Mean time: 2.45 min |
18 | Yanagisawa et al. [39] | 2017 | Cross-sectional | Internal consistency Inter-rater reliability | Caregivers | Institutionalized older people | OAS | 3 point scale on 9 items | Unknown |