Skip to main content

Advertisement

Springer Nature is making SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19 research free. View research | View latest news | Sign up for updates

Table 2 Data-extraction table for the included studies

From: Measurement properties of oral health assessments for non-dental healthcare professionals in older people: a systematic review

 AuthorsPublication yearStudy designInvestigated measurement propertyType of non-dental healthcare professional using assessmentPatient populationOral health assessmentRating scaleDuration of assessment
1Andersson et al. [18]2002Cross-sectional observationalInter-rater reliabilityRNolder people in rehabilitation wardROAG3 point scale on 8 itemsUnknown
2Andersson et al. [25]2002Cross-sectional observationalContent validityRNGeriatric rehabilitation patientsROAG3 point scale on 8 itemsUnknown
3Arvidson-Bufano et al. [26]1996Cross-sectional observationalInter-rater reliabilityRN and LPNNursing home residentsMDS-RAI (section M) and RAP summary2 Point scale on 7 items3–4 min
4Blank et al. [27]1996Cross-sectional observationalInter-rater reliabilityRN and LPNNursing home residentsMDS-RAI (section M) and RAP summary2 Point scale on 7 itemsUnknown
5Chalmers et al. [17]2005Prognostic follow-upContent validity
Criterion validity
Intra-rater reliability
Inter-rater reliability
Test-retest reliability
PCA, RN, Enrolled Nurses and NAResidents from residential facilitiesOHAT3 point scale on 8 itemsMean: 7.8 min
6Cohen-Mansfield et al. [28]2002Cross-sectional observational studyInter-rater reliabilityGeriatriciansNursing home residents with DementiaMDS- mouth pain and inflamed gums8 items on 2 point scaleUnknown
7Dickinson et al. [19]2001Cross-sectional studyContent validity
Intra-rater reliability
Inter-rater reliability
Stroke specialist nurse, staff nurses, student nurseOlder medically Ill patientsTHROAT4 point scale on 9 itemsUnknown
8Fjeld et al. [29]2016Prognostic follow-upContent validity
Criterion validity
Inter-rater reliability
Clinical nurseNursing home residentsDHR3 point scale on two itemsLess than 1 minute
9Hanne et al. [30]2012Cross-sectionalCross-cultural validityNursesAcute medical ward residents (mean age 76.5)ROAG3 point scale on 8 itemsUnknown
10Hawes et al. [31]1995Cross-sectionalInter-rater reliabilityLNNursing home residentsMDSUnclearUnknown
11Henriksen et al. [32]1999Cross-sectionalIntra-rater reliability
Inter-rater reliability
Medical Nurseolder people with mental disabilitiesMPS4 point scale on 2 items2–4 min
12Kayser-Jones et al. [33]1995Cross-sectionalInter-rater reliability
Test-retest reliability
RN, LVN, CNANursing home residentsBOHSE3 point scale on 10 itemsMean time RNs, LVNS, CNAs: 7.4, 7.9 and 8.7 min
13Lin et al. [34]1999Cross-sectionalCriterion validity
Inter-rater reliability
LN and CNALTC residents with AlzheimerBOHSE3 point scale on 10 itemsUnknown
14Morris et al. [35]1997Cross-sectionalInter-rater reliabilityNursesCommunity-dwelling older people with home careMDS-HCUnclearUnknown
15Paulsson et al. [36]2008ProspectiveCriterion validityNursesPatients on medical ward (mean age 67)ROAG3 point scale on 8 itemsUnknown
16Riberio et al. [37]2014Cross-sectionalCross-cultural validity
Criterion validity
Intra-rater reliability
CHWCommunity-dwelling older peopleROAG3 point scale on 8 items11 min
17Simpelaere et al. [38]2016Cross-sectional with two- week follow-up for test-retestIntra-rater reliability
Inter-rater reliability
Test-retest reliability
Speech PathologistsAcute geriatric department/hospitalized, residential care settings (assisted living and nursing homes)OHAT3 point scale on 8 itemsMean time: 2.45 min
18Yanagisawa et al. [39]2017Cross-sectionalInternal consistency
Inter-rater reliability
CaregiversInstitutionalized older peopleOAS3 point scale on 9 itemsUnknown
  1. Non-dental healthcare abbreviations: RN Registered Nurse, LVN Licensed Vocational Nurse, CN Clinical Nurse, LPN Licensed Practical Nurse, DDS Doctoral Dental Surgery, DNS Director of Nursing, CHW Community health workers, NA Nurse assistant, PCA Personal Care Attendants.
  2. Oral health assessment abbreviations: ROAG The Revised Oral Assessment Guide, (2) MDS-RAI/RAP the Minimum Data Set-Resident Assessment Instrument/ Resident Assessment Protocol, OHAT with oral health component, (3) the Oral Health Assessment Tool, (4) THROAT The Holistic Reliable Oral Assessment Tool, (5) DHR Dental Hygiene Registration, (6) MPS Mucosal Plaque Score, (7) BOHSE the Brief Oral Health Screening Examination and the OAS Oral Assessment Sheet