Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of included cohort studies, with outcomes included in review categorised using ICF frameworka

From: A critical review of the long-term disability outcomes following hip fracture

Author, year Country N (hip fracture) Recruitment Activity Participation Health condition Accomm QOL Mortality
Mobility Basic ADL Self care IADLs Domestic Community
Relative to non-fracture group
 Autier 2000 [18]b Belgium 170 1995–1996         Yes   Yes
 Boonen 2004 [19]b Belgium 170 1995–1996 Yes Yes      Yes   Yes Yes
 Cumming 1996 [20] Australia 131 1990–1992         Yes   Yes
 Magaziner 2003c [21] USA 594 1990–1991 Yes   Yes        
 Marottoli 1992d, e [16] USA 120 1982–1988 Yes   Yes        Yes
 Norton 2000 [22] New Zealand 911 1991–1994 Yes Yes         
 Tosteson 2001 [23] USA 67 NR Yes Yes         
 Wolinsky 1997e [17] USA 368 1984–1991 Yes Yes   Yes Yes      Yes
Population-based cohorts
 Bentler 2009 [14] USA 495 1993–2005 Yes Yes   Yes    Yes    Yes
 Marottoli 1994d [15] USA 120 1982–1988         Yes   Yes
No comparison group
 Abimanyi-Ochom 2015 [30] Australia 224 2009–2012          Yes  
 Beaupre 2005 [50]f Canada 919 1999–2000 & 1996–1997   Yes       Yes   Yes
 Beaupre 2007 [48]f Canada 451 1999–2000 Yes Yes Yes        Yes
 Borgquist 1990 [31] Sweden 103 1976–1977 Yes   Yes   Yes Yes   Yes   Yes
 Borgquist 1991 [32] Sweden 837 1986–1988 Yes Yes Yes   Yes Yes   Yes   Yes
 Borgström 2013 [33] International 1273 2003, 2007–2010          Yes  
 Crotty 2000 [49] Australia 215 1998–1999 Yes Yes       Yes   Yes
 Doshi 2014 [61] Singapore 219 2011–NR   Yes         Yes
   Givens 2008 [52] USA 126 NR Yes Yes       Yes   Yes
 Griffin 2015 [46] UK 741 2012–2014 Yes         Yes Yes
 Holt 2008 [62] Scotland 16380 1998–2005 Yes         Yes Yes
 Keene 1993 [41] UK 1000 1989–1992 Yes     Yes     Yes Yes
 Kitamura 1998 [34]g Japan 1169 1992 Yes Yes Yes      Yes   Yes
 Tsuboi 2007 [35]g Japan 963 1992 Yes        Yes   Yes
 Koval 1998 [44] USA 631 1987–1995 Yes          Yes
 Koval 1998 [51] USA 398 1988–1990   Yes   Yes       Yes
 Magaziner 1990 [42] USA 760 1984–1986 Yes Yes   Yes       Yes
 Magaziner 2000c [43] USA 674 1990–1991 Yes Yes Yes   Yes Yes Yes    Yes
 Miller 2009 [40] USA 205 1992–1995   Yes     Yes     
 Morin 2012 [24] Canada 12139 1986–2006         Yes   
 Neuman 2014 [28] USA 60111 2005–2007 Yes Yes     Yes     Yes
 Osnes 2004 [25] Norway 1002 1996–1997 Yes Yes       Yes   
 Pereira 2010 [39] Brazil 246 2001 Yes          Yes
 Pitto 1994 [29] Italy 143 1985–1987    Yes     Yes    Yes
 Samuelsson 2009 [45] Sweden 2134 2003 Yes Yes       Yes   Yes
 Shah 2001 [47] USA 850 1987–1996 Yes Yes   Yes     Yes   Yes
 Ström 2008 [36] Sweden 283 NR          Yes  
 Suriyawongpaisal 2003 [26] Thailand 250 NR Yes   Yes       Yes  
 Vergara 2014 [38] Spain 638 NR   Yes   Yes       
 Vochteloo 2013 [37] Netherlands 390 2008–2009 Yes          Yes
 Wang 2015 [12] China 1151 2008–2012    Yes        Yes
 Wong 2002 [27] Singapore 274 1991–1993 Yes          Yes
  1. aYes indicates how the study outcomes are categorised according to the ICF framework
  2. b, c, d, f, g indicates hip fracture patients from same cohort
  3. ePopulation-based cohort study with comparison to non-fracture group
  4. Accomm accommodations, ADL activities of daily living, IADL instrumental activities of daily living, ICF International Classification of Functioning, NR not reported, QOL quality of life
Back to article page

BMC Geriatrics

ISSN: 1471-2318

Contact us