Skip to main content

Table 5 Methodological quality for studies across seven measurement properties

From: Person-centredness in the care of older adults: a systematic review of questionnaire-based scales and their measurement properties

Measure

Study

Internal consistency

Reliability

Measurement error

Content validity

Structural validity

Hypothesis testing

Cross-cultural

Specific measures

 

 ICI

Chappell et al. [29]

Poor

Fair

 

Poor

Poor

Fair

 
 

Charalambous et al. [30]

Fair

    

Fair

Poor

 

O’Rourke et al. [31]

Good

   

Good

  

 P-CAT

Edvardsson et al. [32]

Good

Poor

 

Good

Good

  
 

Zhong & Lou [33]

Fair

   

Fair

Poor

Poor

 

Sjogren et al. [34]

Excellent

Fair

  

Excellent

 

Poor

 

Rokstad et al. [35]

Excellent

Fair

  

Good

 

Poor

 PCFC

Rose et al. [46]

Excellent

  

Poor

Excellent

  

 PCHC

Dow et al. [48]

Excellent

  

Excellent

Good

  

 PDC

White et al. [47]

Fair

  

Good

Fair

  
 

Sullivan et al. [52]

Fair

  

Poor

   

 ‘Untitled’

Terada et al. [45]

Poor

Poor

 

Poor

   

Generic measures

 

 PCQ (Staff version)

Edvardsson et al. [36]

Fair

    

Fair

 
 

Bergland et al. [37]

Excellent

Fair

 

Poor

Good

Poor

Fair

 PCQ (Patient version)

Bergland et al. [38]

Fair

Fair

 

Poor

 

Poor

Fair

 MPOCA

Bamm et al. [44]

Poor

Fair

 

Poor

 

Fair

 

 CCCQ

de Witte et al. [39]

Excellent

  

Poor

Fair

Poor

 
 

Bruus et al. [40]

Poor

     

Poor

 

Bosman et al. [41]

Fair

    

Poor

 
 

Muntinga et al. [42]

Excellent

Excellent

Excellent

 

Excellent

Poor

 

 ICS-N

Suhonen et al. [43]

Fair

   

Fair

  

 CCRQ

Cott et al. [49]

Poor

Good

 

Excellent

 

Poor

 
  1. Empty cells indicate the property was not assessed in the reference