Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of previous COACH systems.

From: The COACH prompting system to assist older adults with dementia through handwashing: An efficacy study

COACH Version

Tracking System

Decision-making system

Prompting system

Number of Subjects*

Related Publications

Version 1

Pattern wristband worn by the user

Neural networks interacting with a hard-coded taxonomy

Audio prompts, with one prompt for each step

10

[22, 33]

Version 2

Using background subtraction to isolate the user's hands. Tracking of hands and task objects (i.e. soap and towel) using a preset colour model.

Fully observable Markov decision process (MDP). This technique assumes the world is fully observable; it does not take into account hidden variables, such as user responsiveness.

Audio prompts with three levels of assistance (minimal, moderate, and maximal) for each step.

4

[20, 37–39]

Version 3 (system presented in this paper)

Colour based flocking.

[Belief monitoring system & policy] Partially observable Markov decision process (POMDP). This model takes into account hidden variables and is able to make decisions in conditions of uncertainty.

Audio and audio-video prompts with three levels of assistance (minimal, maximal, and maximal + video demonstration) for each step. Encouragement and a reminder regarding the activity the user is attempting added. Professional actor recorded prompts.

6

[18, 19, 21, 23, 25]

  1. * Results from previous trials are not presented as they are not comparable because of the variance in the technologies and procedures that were used.